Games Like Phasmophobia With a Story: 8 Co-op Horror Campaigns You Can Finish
Phasmophobia has no campaign. Every contract is one location, one ghost and one exit, and the only thing that carries between nights is your level and your gear — the store page describes it as a 4-player online co-op loop, and the listing still carries Steam's Early Access tag. If you want a co-op horror game with a beginning, a middle and an ending, choose by who is playing: The Blackout Club for four players and a town-sized mystery, Aliens: Fireteam Elite for three players and four campaigns, Green Hell if the story has to last 25 hours, and Dead Space 3 or Resident Evil 5 if it is just the two of you. Every price, review row and language table below is a Steam snapshot taken on November 1, 2026, with a sale live at the time of checking.
Quick picks by what you want from the story
| Your group | First pick | Why this one | Skip it if… |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 players, wants a mystery | The Blackout Club | Drop-in/drop-out sessions for 1–4, missions that change with your level, and an enemy you can only see with your eyes closed. | You want a fight you can win by aiming. |
| 3 players, wants sci-fi | Aliens: Fireteam Elite | The listing says "play with up to two players or AI" across four campaigns and twelve missions. | You want horror first and shooting second. |
| Wants the longest story | Green Hell | A 25+ hour story campaign, plus a separate 20+ hour prequel campaign, for $2.49 on the day of checking. | You want a game that respects your evening. |
| Wants to watch a story together | The Quarry | Steam lists split-screen co-op, and the store text describes a vote-based mode for friends who own the full game. | Everyone wants to play from their own PC online — Steam does not list online co-op here. |
| Only two of you | Resident Evil 5 | Steam lists Co-op, and the campaign is written as a two-hander between Chris and Sheva. | You want a modern port: the page says it is a port of the 2009 Games for Windows – Live version. |
The 8 campaigns at a glance
Review figures are the English-review summaries shown on each store page with the store language set to English, and the last-30-days column is Steam's separate recent-review row. Player counts are quoted only where the listing text states a number; "not stated" means the page checked gave none — not that the game is single-player. Phasmophobia is the first row as the reference point, not a recommendation.
| Game | Players (as listed) | What the story actually is | US price, Nov 1, 2026 | Steam reviews (English) | Last 30 days | Simplified Chinese |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Phasmophobia | 4 | No campaign: single contracts, progress is level and gear | $13.99 (30% off $19.99) | Very Positive, 94% of 360,726 | 86% of 2,726 | Yes |
| The Blackout Club | 1–4, drop-in/drop-out | Procedural missions that vary with player level, wrapped around one town mystery | $14.99 (50% off $29.99) | Mostly Positive, 77% of 1,628 | No recent row shown | No |
| Sons of the Forest | Not stated | Survival story on an island you are sent to search | $8.39 (72% off $29.99) | Very Positive, 88% of 119,252 | 90% of 3,334 | Yes |
| Green Hell | Not stated | A 25+ hour campaign, plus a 20+ hour prequel campaign | $2.49 (90% off $24.99) | Very Positive, 85% of 27,600 | 81% of 1,148 | Yes |
| Aliens: Fireteam Elite | 3 — "up to two players or AI" | Four campaigns, twelve missions; the Pathogen expansion adds three more | $5.99 (80% off $29.99) | Very Positive, 82% of 14,389 | 69% of 69 | Yes |
| The Quarry | Not stated | A branching cinematic story with nine counselors and a vote-based group mode | $5.99 (90% off $59.99) | Very Positive, 83% of 8,432 | 79% of 388 | Yes |
| The Dark Pictures: Man of Medan | 2 online, 5 offline | A branching story on a ghost ship, played with one friend or five | $7.99 (60% off $19.99) | Mostly Positive, 74% of 3,569 | 74% of 79 | Yes |
| Dead Space 3 | Not stated | The full campaign, playable in online co-op or solo | $19.99 (no discount) | Mixed, 68% of 5,366 | 67% of 152 | No |
| Resident Evil 5 | Not stated | A two-character campaign through a bio-terror outbreak | $4.99 (75% off $19.99) | Very Positive, 84% of 19,351 | 85% of 822 | No |
Four players: The Blackout Club is the closest thing to a campaign on this shelf
The Blackout Club is the only pick here built around a mystery that resolves. Its listing describes 1–4 player drop-in/drop-out sessions, procedurally generated missions that vary according to player level and progress, and — the detail that sells it — an enemy you can only see with your eyes closed. That last rule changes how a group talks: somebody has to shut their eyes on purpose while the rest of you keep watch, which is a better co-op hook than another ghost to photograph.
The cost is age and reach. It sits at 77% of 1,628 English reviews, its store page showed no recent-review row at all on November 1, and the language table lists English, French, German, Spanish and Russian only — no Simplified Chinese. If your group needs Chinese text, this is the one pick on the page that fails.
Three players: Aliens: Fireteam Elite runs four campaigns
Fireteam Elite is the only row here with a stated three-player design: "play with up to two players or AI as you battle through four campaigns". The base game ships twelve missions, and the Pathogen expansion adds a campaign of three more. Steam also lists the Cross-Platform Multiplayer category for it, which matters if one of your three is on a console.
The honest warning is the score. Lifetime it sits at 82% of 14,389 English reviews, but the last-30-day row reads 69% of 69 — a small sample, and the kind of split that usually means recent buyers hit something specific they did not like. At $5.99 it is cheap enough to test, but do not buy it expecting a horror game: it is a third-person shooter wearing an Alien skin.
If the story is the point: Green Hell and Sons of the Forest
Green Hell is the outlier of the whole list on price and length at once. Its store text promises a 25+ hour campaign following anthropologist Jake Higgins, plus a free prequel campaign, Spirits of Amazonia, with over 20 hours in it. On November 1 the game was 90% off at $2.49, with 85% of 27,600 English reviews and 81% of 1,148 recent. What it does not give you is a stated co-op cap — the page says "play solo or team up with friends" and stops there.
Sons of the Forest has the same gap and a different tone: you are sent to find a missing billionaire, the island is full of cannibals, and the listing's co-op section is one line — "survive alone, or with friends". No number. It does have the strongest recent score on the page (90% of 3,334) against a lifetime 88% of 119,252, and at $8.39 it is the cheapest way to get a long horror campaign with a friend. Both games are survival first: if your group wants objectives handed to you, this is the wrong shelf.
If you want to watch a story as a group: The Quarry and Man of Medan
Read the Steam category labels before the trailer on both of these, because they disagree with how people describe the games.
The Quarry lists Co-op and Shared/Split Screen Co-op, and does not list online co-op. Its store text describes Wolf Pack Mode, where friends who own the full version of the game on Steam join and vote on key decisions, plus a couch co-op mode where each player picks a counselor. So "co-op" here means a shared screen or a voting audience, not four people playing from four PCs. It is 83% of 8,432 English reviews and was 90% off at $5.99.
Man of Medan is the mirror image: Steam labels it PvP, Online PvP and Shared/Split Screen PvP, with no co-op category at all, while the store text says you can experience the story "with a friend online or go for safety in numbers with up to five players offline". Two people, two roles, one story — the label just calls it PvP. At 74% of 3,569 it is the weakest-reviewed of the cinematic picks, and its recent row is identical at 74% of 79.
If there are only two of you: Dead Space 3 and Resident Evil 5
Dead Space 3's listing is unusually direct: "Play the full campaign in online co-op or single-player." There is no separate co-op mode to unlock and no second campaign to buy — the co-op is the story. The problems are the ones that come with a 2013 game: it sits at 68% of 5,366 English reviews (Mixed) with a 67% recent row, it has no Simplified Chinese, and at $19.99 on November 1 it was the only title on this page with no discount at all while everything around it was 50–90% off.
Resident Evil 5 is the cheapest finished campaign here at $4.99, and its store page is candid about what you are buying: a port of the 2009 Games for Windows – Live version. Steam lists Co-op, the story is written for Chris and Sheva together, and 84% of 19,351 English reviews still hold up with an 85% recent row. Neither this nor Dead Space 3 states a player number in its listing text, so if the lobby size decides the purchase, check before you both buy.
When not to buy any of these
- You want the evidence loop. None of these eight has an EMF reader, a spirit box or a journal. If identifying a ghost is the part you like, the Phasmophobia alternatives list is built around that loop instead.
- You want to fight back. Only Fireteam Elite and Dead Space 3 are shooters first. For action-horror co-op as a category, the Phasmophobia with combat picks cover that shelf properly.
- You need Simplified Chinese. Skip The Blackout Club, Dead Space 3 and Resident Evil 5 — none of the three lists it. Everything else here does.
- You are playing solo. These are campaigns written for a group; the single-player Phasmophobia picks are the better list if nobody else is buying.
- You want an online lobby of four from four PCs. The Quarry and Man of Medan are shared-screen or two-player-online stories, not four-player online sessions. The co-op horror on Steam guide covers the games that do fill a four-person online lobby.
- You are buying on score alone. Dead Space 3 at 68% and Man of Medan at 74% are the two most likely to disappoint; both are cheap, but neither is a safe blind buy.
Price and listing note
All prices are US Steam figures captured on November 1, 2026, during a sale that was live at the time of checking — eight of the nine rows above carry a discount, and those expire. Review percentages come from the same date and will move; the recent-review column is Steam's own last-30-days row and is shown separately because a small sample can swing it. Player counts are quoted from the listing text where a number appears, and marked "not stated" where it does not: that is a limit of the page checked, not a claim about the game. Language columns are copied from Steam's language table for the same date. Check the linked store page before buying, especially for the four rows whose player cap the listing never gives.
Sources checked November 1, 2026
- Steam store pages for all nine games above, with the store region set to the United States and the language set to English: price, review summary rows, category labels, player text and language tables.
- Steam category labels as shown on each page, including the absence of an online-co-op label on The Quarry and the absence of a co-op label on Man of Medan.
- No Search Console or keyword-volume data was used in this article; none was available for this run and none was estimated.